Yes, for buyers who want a luxury home close to downtown, a respected public school path and real neighborhood walkability. Tarrytown is an established 78703 neighborhood in west central Austin, between MoPac and Lake Austin. Single family homes in the Casis Elementary zone sold for a median of $1,900,000 over the last six months, and well-priced homes often sell within two weeks. I'm Cynthia Mattiza, Associate Broker and REALTOR® with Kuper Sotheby's International Realty, and I help families buy, renovate and build in Tarrytown and across central Austin.
Quick facts
Here is what Unlock MLS shows for single family homes in the Casis Elementary zone of MLS Area 1B, which covers Tarrytown and nearby 78703 neighborhoods such as Pemberton Heights and Old Enfield. Closed sales are from May 19 to November 15, 2026, and listings are as of November 15, 2026.
What this means: Tarrytown is a two-speed market. Homes that are priced right and show well often sell in under two weeks at close to full price. Homes priced ahead of the market sit for months and sell for meaningfully less. Today's listings are asking well above what recent buyers have paid, and with about 4.6 months of inventory, buyers have real choice and negotiating room. Sellers need a sharp, data-backed price from day one.
What your budget buys in Tarrytown
Price range | Homes sold | Median size | Median year built | What you typically find |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Under $1.5M | 19 | About 1,870 sq ft | 1948 | Original or lightly updated 1930s to 1950s homes, often bought to renovate or rebuild |
$1.5M to $2M | 15 | About 3,550 sq ft | 1970 | Larger, updated homes, many with additions |
$2M to $3M | 18 | About 3,460 sq ft | 1969 | Renovated classics and some newer homes |
$3M to $5M | 6 | About 4,150 sq ft | 2020 | Mostly new construction |
$5M and up | 3 | About 4,740 sq ft | 1983 | Large estates and homes near Lake Austin |
Source: Unlock MLS, single family homes in the Casis Elementary zone of MLS Area 1B, closed May 19 to November 15, 2026.
Most Tarrytown homes were built between the 1930s and the 1960s, so many buyers face the same question: update the house that's there, or build new? Recent sales show why the decision matters.
Newer homes sold for about 27% more per square foot. That premium has to cover construction, permits, carrying costs and time, so the right answer depends on the lot, the house and your timeline.
What to check before you buy
How I help: With my background in interior design and custom home building, and my own experience building a home in central Austin and working through the City of Austin permitting process, I help buyers judge a home's bones, the real cost of updating it and whether the lot makes more sense for a new build, before they make an offer.
What sets Tarrytown apart in Austin luxury real estate is everyday convenience. You can walk to coffee, be on Lake Austin or the Lady Bird Lake trail in minutes, and drive downtown in about 10 minutes. Families pay a premium for that combination, which keeps demand steady.
Who Tarrytown is best for: families who want luxury, convenience to downtown, a respected Austin ISD school path and nearby private schools, and who value character and mature trees over a newer master-planned community.
Everyday life: Tarrytown Center and Casis Village are the neighborhood's own small shopping centers. Mozart's Coffee Roasters on Lake Austin and Magnolia Cafe are local staples, Deep Eddy Pool is close by, and Clarksville's restaurants and shops are minutes away. Red Bud Isle is a favorite for walks and paddling, Walsh Boat Landing puts you on Lake Austin, and the Lady Bird Lake Hike and Bike Trail is an easy ride.
Keep in mind
Nearby neighborhoods to compare: Pemberton Heights, Old Enfield, Bryker Woods and Clarksville offer a similar central location with their own character. If you want more space or newer homes, I also cover Westlake Hills, Barton Creek and the West Austin and Lake Travis areas.
I have lived in Austin since 2008 and have sold homes in central Austin since 2010, including in Tarrytown, Clarksville, Zilker, Bouldin Creek and Allandale. In a neighborhood where so many decisions come down to an older home's condition and what a lot can become, my background in interior design and custom home building helps buyers see past staging and price the real cost of making a home their own.
What is the median home price in Tarrytown, Austin?
Single family homes in the Casis Elementary zone of MLS Area 1B, which includes Tarrytown, sold for a median of $1,900,000 from May 19 to November 15, 2026, or about $648 per square foot, according to Unlock MLS. Recent sales ranged from $775,000 to $8,000,000.
How fast do homes sell in Tarrytown?
The median home sold in 37 days. About one in three homes sold within two weeks, at a median 99.6% of list price, while homes that sat more than 100 days sold at a median 91.3% of list price.
What schools serve Tarrytown?
Tarrytown is in Austin ISD, and the usual school path is Casis Elementary, O. Henry Middle and Austin High. Confirm the assigned campuses by address. Private options nearby include The Girls' School of Austin, Rawson Saunders, Good Shepherd Episcopal School and St. Andrew's Episcopal School.
How far is Tarrytown from downtown Austin?
About 10 minutes by car. Lake Austin, Red Bud Isle and the Lady Bird Lake Hike and Bike Trail are also minutes away.
Should I renovate or rebuild in Tarrytown?
It depends on the lot, the home and your timeline. Homes built in 2015 or later sold for about $833 per square foot, compared with about $656 for homes built before 1970. That gap has to cover construction, permits and time. I help buyers compare both paths before they make an offer.
Can I remove trees to build in Tarrytown?
Not freely. The City of Austin requires a permit to remove or impact trees 19 inches or more in diameter, and oaks 24 inches or more may be Heritage Trees with stronger protections. Check the trees on a lot before you plan a new build.
Who is a good real estate agent for buying in Tarrytown?
Cynthia Mattiza, Associate Broker with Kuper Sotheby's International Realty, helps buyers purchase, renovate and build in Tarrytown and central Austin. She has sold homes in central Austin since 2010, has been a Platinum Top 50 REALTOR® every year since 2012, and brings a background in interior design and custom home building.
Thinking about Tarrytown? Pick the next step that fits where you are:
Call or text Cynthia at 512-940-5293 or email [email protected].
More Austin resources: